
Knocking On Heaven’s Door
Ever since the Fox sisters began talking to the spirit of a dead man in their home during 1848, spiritualists, mediums and psychics have sprung up to connect the living and the dead.
You can read about the Fox sisters here, if you’re unfamiliar with the story – https://scepticonline.com/2024/02/17/the-fox-sisters-pioneers-or-showgirls/
But is it really possible to talk to the dead?
You couldn’t throw a stick these days without hitting someone who has visited a psychic or knows someone who has. Holding a psychic night or a seance, or visiting a theatre to watch a medium on stage, is still a valid form of entertainment today as much as it was when the Fox sisters took their show on the road.
I remember as a teenager in the North West of England going to many psychic nights at friends houses and being awed by what they told me. I was much more naive in my younger years and used to go home to my dear old Mum telling her everything and asking if she knew a ‘Geoff’ or a ‘John’ who came through to talk to me. We must have been one of the only households who didn’t have a ‘John’ in the family so we’d be wracking our brains for hours trying to decipher the information. Of course, we never did. I even got told I would have a job in the public eye one day and be very successful at it. Obviously this was one of those things they tell everybody, along with ‘I can tell you have the gift too’.
Seances And Canopes
From the minute that the Fox Sisters became famous around the world, people began to profess to also being able to talk to the dead. One of the favourite past times of the Victorian and Edwardian eras was to hold an after dinner seance, with stiff competition as to who could bring the best psychic medium to the party.

Invitations to these events were highly sought after with people desperate to talk to their dear departed loved ones, and the bigger the spectacle, the better.
It was also a very lucrative living, especially for women of the day, who were discouraged from doing much else than bearing children and keeping house. They could now excel at their own career earning a very decent wage, so no longer had to depend on a man.
Sceptics and Debunkers
Along with the believers who would pay dearly to see a psychic medium in action, came the sceptics and debunkers, the most famous being Harry Houdini.
Psychics were placed inside spirit cabinets and the doors shut tight, to ensure that there was no trickery when they communed with spirits, but sceptics felt that this only hid the many things that they could get up to.
Other ways of ensuring that readings went smoothly was to tie the psychics hands and feet to a chair so that they couldn’t move to make any knocking sounds. They would be watched intensely to ensure that communications were genuine, no matter that their assistants could be faking any noise from the other side of the room.

Manifestations would come in the form of ectoplasm spewing forth from psychics mouths and other orifices. One psychic even did readings naked, producing items from her lady parts. Saucy!
The sceptics of the day insisted that ectoplasm, that genuinely looked like a wet sheet, could be ingested and then regurgitated from a persons stomach. And flying objects such as musical instruments or children’s toys could be rigged to move about the room by some elaborate system.
As most seances and readings were done in the dark or by candlelight, this was very easy to do.
Fame and Fortune
One of the most famous spiritualist mediums known in the UK was Scottish woman Helen Duncan.
She was born in Callander in 1897 and travelled around the country performing seances where she produced ectoplasm from her mouth. In the photo above, you can see how ridiculous the manifestations looked, but at the time, people believed it.

During World War 2, Helen was performing in Portsmouth in the UK, when the government took an interest in what she was saying.
In 1941, Helen allegedly spoke to a deceased sailor from the war ship HMS Barham who said that the ship had sunk in the Mediterranean. The War Office had not released this information to the public, so they began keeping an eye on Duncan, trying to keep the fact that 861 men had died when the Barham was hit by a German U-Boat.
During a seance in January 1944, Helen was arrested and eventually brought to trial at the Old Bailey, prosecuted under the Witchcraft Act of 1735 for having ‘supernatural powers’. She was sentenced to 9 months in prison with no chance of appeal – serving her time in London’s Holloway Prison.
The Witchcraft Act was thought to be antiquated and was repealed in 1951, leaving all psychics and witches heaving a sigh of relief. The government now recognised witchcraft and spiritualism as a religion.
Helen Duncan continued to be scrutinised by the law, with several more attempts at arrest during the rest of her career, until she passed away in 1956, forever known as the last witch.
The Spirit Phone
With morse code being an important form of communication in the early 1900s, it makes sense that the rappings of spirit communication were held in comparison to the dots and dashes of the telegraph.
It’s no surprise then, that Thomas Edison began working on a spirit communication device, or spirit phone, that people could use to communicate with the dearly deceased.
It seems that he never finished his design, leaving F. R. Melton to invent his own psychical telephone. This was tested on a medium in 1932 but was apparently unsuccessful.
Radio waves still seem to be the preferred method of communing with the dead today, with many ghost hunters and vigils relying heavily on EVP recordings – Electronic Voice Phenomenon – to receive messages. There is even a thing called a ‘ghost box’ which cycles through radio frequencies spitting out random words at speed that is believed to be voices from the other side.
I don’t believe the ‘ghost box’ is anything but an expensive gimmick, but if you think about the radio signals we have been sending to outer space to find evidence of life on other planets, then it seems to be a valid form of communication.
Can You Learn To Talk To The Dead, Or Is It A Gift We’re Born With?
It was thought for a long time that you had to be born with the ‘gift’ or have suffered some kind of near death experience to be able to see or talk to the dead. Babies born with a partial caul, which was a membrane covering their face that had to be cut away, were thought to be psychic. Many people have woken from comas or some kind of head injury believing that they not only saw long dead relatives on the other side during their experience, but could still see and hear them after they were revived.
Now days, there are endless courses available to anybody that wants to part with their hard earned cash can learn to develop their psychic ability, or how to talk to dead people. I myself, researching this article, paid out hundreds of pounds that I don’t really have spare, to do a few. These ranged from £59 to £695, lasted between 6 and 20 weeks, and taught me nothing except that I’m NOT psychic.
I’ve had one to one readings with spiritualist mediums, went to a group psychic night, and paid to see a medium on stage who spent the whole night walking up and down doing nothing but throwing out random names and places that nobody in the audience knew. About half the audience left at the interval, he was that good.
So is it possible to talk to the dead?
I have found no evidence to say that it is. Even if I believed any of the psychics who I’ve seen over the last couple of months, there’s no proof that they aren’t cold reading or second guessing anything that’s coming out of their mouths. Because there is absolutely no way on this planet that we can prove that they’re talking to the deceased. We basically have to just take their word for it. And those who say they’ve heard different voices coming out of a psychics mouth? Well, I’ve been known to do one or two very convincing impressions in my lifetime.
So my quest goes on. I will continue trying to find that one genuine psychic medium, and maybe try and chat to my dear departed Mama, because I do miss her. I doubt it’s ever going to happen though, and it will be a huge waste of time and money.
You’ll be the first to know if it does.
Sign up to follow my site if you’re enjoying Sceptic’s articles.
Leave a Reply